When a business owner asks me whether they need a bookkeeper or an accountant, I start with what they need help with.
Are the books behind? Are tax deadlines becoming a worry? Or are the records up to date, but nobody is helping them understand what the numbers mean?
The job titles are useful, but they don't tell you everything. What matters is the work included, who takes responsibility for it and how the people involved work together.
What does a bookkeeper do?
A bookkeeper keeps your financial records organised and up to date. That usually includes recording income and expenses, matching bank transactions to the records, and keeping track of customer invoices and supplier bills.
Depending on the service agreed, they may also handle VAT returns, payroll and management reports. Those tasks aren't automatically included just because someone offers bookkeeping.
A good bookkeeper can help you spot missing information, overdue payments and problems with cash flow. Their work isn't just about recording what happened. Reliable, current records help you decide what to do next.
What does an accountant do?
An accountant may prepare year-end accounts and tax returns, advise on tax and business structure, and help you understand your financial position.
Some also provide management accounts, forecasts and regular business advice. Others focus on accounts and filing. Don't assume ongoing advice comes with a year-end service. Ask what you will receive and when.
I've covered this in more detail in what a good accountant actually does.
Where do their roles overlap?
Bookkeepers and accountants can both work on reporting, VAT and the checks that keep your records accurate. The division depends on their skills, experience and the service you agree.
You don't necessarily need separate providers. You do need clear responsibilities. Who checks the bookkeeping? Who deals with a transaction that needs tax advice? Who makes sure the records are ready for the accounts?
If you use separate firms, ask how they share information and resolve questions. If you use the same firm, ask the same questions. Being under the same name doesn't explain how the work gets handed over.
Signs you need bookkeeping help
I would look at what is happening in your business rather than use a transaction count as the deciding factor.
- Your bank reconciliations are overdue.
- You have figures in your software, but you don't trust them.
- Deadlines are missed or everything gets rushed just before they arrive.
- Too many evenings go on receipts, invoices and financial admin.
Those are reasons to review the support you have. If the records aren't reliable, it is harder to make useful decisions from them.
When do you need an accountant?
A limited company has legal filing obligations, including accounts and a confirmation statement, and a Company Tax Return where required. Appointing an accountant isn't itself a legal requirement. The directors remain responsible for meeting the company's obligations.
Professional help can be useful when you aren't confident about those requirements, need advice on tax or business structure, or want someone to review what the figures mean for your plans.
For a sole trader, the decision also depends on the work involved and the knowledge and time available. Ask for support that fits your circumstances rather than assuming every business needs the same package.
What should you check is included?
Before comparing proposals, I would ask each provider these questions:
- How often will the bank accounts be reconciled, and what do you need from me?
- Are VAT returns included, and who checks and submits them?
- Will I receive management reports, and will someone explain them?
- Who reviews the work, and what are their qualifications and experience?
- Who keeps track of filing deadlines and outstanding information?
- How do I ask questions, who answers them and what support is included?
- How does the bookkeeping pass into the year-end accounts and tax work?
Ask for the answers in writing. It is much easier to compare services when you know what each proposal actually covers.
What about the cost?
Compare the work included, not just the fee. Keeping records up to date, preparing returns and providing regular advice are different responsibilities.
For cost guidance, see our bookkeeper cost guide and accountant cost guide. Then ask what applies to your business and whether anything you need sits outside the proposed service.
How we work at Gro
At Gro, our bookkeeping team and accountants work under one roof at our Cheltenham office, 122 Bath Road. The books feed straight into the year-end accounts, tax and Profit First reports.
If you want to understand how that fits together, start with our Cheltenham bookkeeping service.
Which does your business need?
If the records are behind, start by sorting out the bookkeeping. If you need help with accounts, tax or decisions about the business, check what accountancy support you need alongside it.
You may need both types of work, but not necessarily separate providers. The aim is to have reliable records and the right help using them.
If you'd like to talk through what you need, you can book a Free Profit Meeting.